Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results?

Is Google playing with a new search result display… and also testing image recognition?

Guest blogger Jenise Uehara Henrikson is in internet marketing, focusing on urban clothing and streetwear.

Update: This article is NOT about Google’s “universal search” which includes images, as well as news and video mixed in the site results. This post documents something new that Google Search appears to be testing only in smaller markets. What’s different about it? Read the (entire) post.

I was doing some research on google.se (Swedish localized Google) when I came across some interesting search results.

In case your Swedish is rusty :) “vigselringar” means “wedding rings”.

googleimagerecognition Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results? picture

googlethumbnailssearchresults Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results? picture

How is the above different from the image results in Google’s universal search?

  1. Unlike universal search, the images above are all from the same website.
  2. The images are listed in-line with the URL listing. Universal search displays images as a separate result.
  3. When any of the images are clicked, all go directly to the site URL listed, not Google Images.
  4. The images displayed are smaller than images shown in Google Universal Search.
  5. Notice that there are no other Universal Search elements: no news articles, no videos.

Why do the images show for the third search result and not the first?

I’m hazarding a guess that Google is using a separate algorithm in order to determine which listing gets their thumbnails displayed:

Attempt to identify keyword-relevant, onpage images.  Add them up. The site with the most KW-relevant, onpage images = winner.

Total number of unique, onpage images:

  1. vigselringar.se: 32
  2. vigselbutiken.se: 32
  3. hellkes.se: 33
  4. handsweden.se: 11
  5. brollopsguiden.se: 38 (note this site has the most images, but NONE of wedding rings)
  6. vigselring.nu: 11
  7. juveler.com: 21
  8. guldgruvan.se: 18
  9. guldbolaget.se: 5
  10. forlovningsringar.se: 2

Number of images where image focus is a wedding ring:

  1. vigselringar.se: 12
  2. vigselbutiken.se: 8
  3. hellkes.se: 19 = winner
  4. handsweden.se: 1
  5. brollopsguiden.se: None (not including ads)
  6. vigselring.nu: 2
  7. juveler.com: none
  8. guldgruvan.se: 4
  9. guldbolaget.se: uses flash
  10. forlovningsringar.se: 1

How is Google selecting which thumbnails to display in the results?

Some possible criteria:

  • Selection by popularity.
  • Random selection.
  • Google image labeler. I did not do a comprehensive search, but it appears google.se does not have the image labeler game available on the google.com site.
  • Selection by relevancy to head keywords. This could indicate Google is using some kind of image recognition technology, because most of the thumbnails above do not have keywords in the alt text or file names.

Below are the 9 of 34 images that Google picked to be listed in the search results. (One image has a question mark, as it is actually slightly different from the one displayed in the search results, although it appears to be the same ring. Possible it was changed recently.)

googlethumbnailselection Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results? picture

When searching for different keywords, I found that the thumbnail selection is identical for the same site.

Below are search results for “hellkes”. Hellke is a common Swedish surname and has no intrinsic meaning linked to jewelry or rings. Same images are displayed.

hellkessearch Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results? picture

Let’s try a different category. Below is a search for “horoskop” (“horoscope”).

In this search, there are two thumbnail displays for two different listings. Note again most of the images chosen are directly relevant to the keyword, as they are representations of astrological signs.

googleimagerecognition3 Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results? picture

The thumbnails do not appear in every search on Google.se. Here’s universal search results in the usual format for keyword “Skansen” which is a famous Swedish museum and zoo.

imagerecognitionbygoogle Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results? picture

More data:
1) Not logged in to Google
2) The thumbnails only show in my Firefox browser, but not in Internet Explorer
3) The thumbnails do not show in other computers’ browsers on same IP
4) Only observed on first page results, if they appear at all

Is Google Search experimenting on google.se? I look forward to the SEO experts following up on this.

Comments

13 Responses to “Google Experimenting with Images in Search Results?”

  1. Search SEO Guru on June 9th, 2009 11:21 pm

    Are the dimensions of the image important by any chance???

  2. wil reynolds on June 9th, 2009 11:48 pm

    Great catch brent, appreciate you sharing it.

  3. Navin Poeran on June 9th, 2009 11:56 pm

    Very nice research. I wonder how much traffic goes to those images…

  4. Glen on June 10th, 2009 12:15 am

    Already covered at Blogstorm.co.uk – you can find the same results in English when you search for 'personal development books'

    Nice write-up though

  5. Barry Schwartz on June 10th, 2009 12:25 am
  6. brentcsutoras on June 10th, 2009 12:31 am

    Actually just tried the 'personal development books' and it doesn't show the images currently. Wonder if they pulled it in the US?

  7. Jenise on June 10th, 2009 2:50 am

    The thumbnails I wrote about stopped showing up for me entirely about an hour after this article was published. Google yanked?

  8. Jenise on June 10th, 2009 2:55 am

    Image size may very well be a factor. That certainly would be a simpler solution than image recognition. It seemed to be factoring out banners, tall images etc..

  9. Tom - Estate on June 10th, 2009 6:54 am

    Nice catch. I experimented a bit allso and allso tested with the names of files. Using a describing filename helps.

  10. Evav on June 10th, 2009 12:09 pm

    I don't know if something is different about my American Google account, but I've been seeing this sort of thing for many months.

  11. Alex Turpin on July 11th, 2009 2:49 am

    I sure hope your girlfriend doesn't read your blog because you kinda spoiled the surprise on her.

  12. Tjeerd | Maxdoro on July 23rd, 2009 7:30 pm

    nice research. I am very inrested to no how much traffic goes to those images..

  13. @Abzetdin_Adamov on September 30th, 2010 2:07 am

    This article really has helped me to understand some issues on google search I'm going to implement…

Leave a Reply